5 Reasons Why King of Scars by Leigh Bardugo Didn’t Work For Me


King of Scars

by Leigh Bardugo

ebook, 528 pages

Published January 29th 2019 by Imprint

Nikolai Lantsov has always had a gift for the impossible. No one knows what he endured in his country’s bloody civil war—and he intends to keep it that way. Now, as enemies gather at his weakened borders, the young king must find a way to refill Ravka’s coffers, forge new alliances, and stop a rising threat to the once-great Grisha Army.

Yet with every day a dark magic within him grows stronger, threatening to destroy all he has built. With the help of a young monk and a legendary Grisha Squaller, Nikolai will journey to the places in Ravka where the deepest magic survives to vanquish the terrible legacy inside him. He will risk everything to save his country and himself. But some secrets aren’t meant to stay buried—and some wounds aren’t meant to heal.


When I asked for a Nikolai book, I didn’t ask for this.

Image result for what a mess gif

Let’s start from the beginning. Initially, I was excited. The first few chapters felt like coming home; if you know me, you know I love TGT more than SoC. So yeah, this book felt like coming home. To see Ravka again, walk the halls of the Little Palace and Os Alta, to see the Grisha in training and met familiar characters…. it was home. So where did it went wrong?

01. The too-descriptive writing

I realized this a few chapters later. You can’t read this book if you haven’t read The Grisha Trilogy and Six of Crows trilogy as this book refers to a lot of events and characters happening in the previous series. Especially the Grisha trilogy, because this book directly deals with the impact of the Civil War. Yet Bardugo feels the need to explain everything again and again: Zoya’s blue kefta and her sharp behavious, Nikolai’s golden hair and his charm, as well as Nina’s love for waffles and changing power, the Grisha’s orders, and many more. Once or twice in the beginning is fine, but continuously throughout the book? It became redundant.

02. Nina’s chapter being too long and removing myself from the story

Speaking about Nina, she became my second hurdle. Nina’s chapters took half of the book. Like literal half. And for a series that titled “Nikolai’s Duology”, the other half was divided between Nikolai, Zoya, and Isaak. What is this?? Nina’s story doesn’t even have anything to do with the happenings in Ravka, nor we see any interactions between them.  Her povs should be its own novella, as it doesn’t have correlation with the happenings in the Ravka and jarred me with the differences. If SJM can do it, Leigh Bardugo can do it. It would be better rather than allocate half of the book about Nikolai and Ravka dealing with the Civil War to another story in faraway land with no correlation at all.

I mean, I can see where the story leads on with that ending, but it just drags the whole book.

03. The characters

Look, I love them. Like I said, it felt like coming home to see these characters again. And I know it won’t be the same, the event in Ruin and Rising are still fresh in their mind and they are still dealing with it. But they just blurred together to me most of the time, with the same wit and choice of words, and how they all just seem to be able to throw sarcasm around in all situation. Like all of them. Yes, we do get glimpses into their minds, but only in Nikolai and Zoya’s povs-the latter who saved this book for me. It just doesn’t make sense!

The Nikolai I knew would not joke when the country is at the brink of war and he’s faced with a crisis, we’ve seen him dealing with crisis a lot in TGT. Neither would Zoya, she may be sharp and sarcastic, but she’s not witty. Neither did Tolya and Tamar. Maybe they already bonded in this book and with the threat of The Darkling gone, they are more comfortable and therefore banter around. But it just really unsettles me.

04. The romance

I’ve seen the potential of Nikolai/Zoya since the ending of R&R, so I should be happy that the hints are there in this book right? Well, I take it back. While I initially thought Zoya’s snark and no bullshit attitude will balance Nikolai’s, in this book, it’s all they talk with. It’s like they couldn’t speak like normal person. Not only that, but the whole Triumvirate and Nik’s inner circle speaks in witty attitude all the damn time. It’s getting too much.

And speaking of romance, why does everyone has to be paired off in this world? Can’t we have single character??? I hate it when an author does this, and Bardugo is no exception.

05. The ending


Look, I love the Darkling. I hated it when he was killed in Ruin and Rising; he had so many potentials and stories to be explored! His methods are definitely wrong, but his intention is only to protect his people, the Grisha, from persecution. All this time, the people in power could stop it if only they care about the Grisha, but they did not so he took power for himself. I would do anything to see him again, to get more of his story.

But this is not it.

In this book, we saw how much his actions affect others. The scars he left behind and the people he killed. We spent almost a whole book to learn about these bad things that still affects these people even though the war ended years ago, and then use one of these people, one that actually suffers the worst, to act as his hocrux???

Image result for what is this gif

I don’t think it voids the ending of the original series. It did not, it serves as an extension of the story. But this? Using Nikolai like this? That is the final nail in the coffin for me. We finally got a Nikolai book, only for his povs to be the least (only second to Isaak) and have his whole story, his whole journey in this book, to be The Darkling hocrux. To bring him back. Yes, the Darkling is under their thumb now and yes, I can’t wait to see them working together. It will be epic. But it really pisses me off how Nikolai is used in this book and how we were all promised.

post divider

On a small unrelated note, this is why I think authors should have ARCs, no matter how established you are. It’s not like I will get one anyway, a small international blogger who lives in the middle of nowhere. But I do noticed EVERYONE (okay, at least 90%) complained about Nina’s chapters. Some are willing to overlook it and still gave this book high ratings, but the fact that we all agree on one thing showed how important readers input are.

Ultimately, this book is a disappointment. Other than the world building, the nostalgic feelings, and the awesomeness that is Zoya, this book is a supreme let down. The writing was  too descriptive, the plot dragged, and Nikolai is used in a worst way possible. Will I still read the second book? Of course. I told you I love a certain someone, there are just so many ways it could lead to an epic team-up we deserve and certain someone being held accountable. Not to mention the power struggle that might be happening, all the ways the certain someone could control Nikolai in return (he is the owner of merzost inside Nikolai), and all the ways Alina’s ass could be dragged back into this mess from the retirement. And of course, the possibility of The Dregs joining the war!! More epic team up!! But for this one, I would say that this book is really not what I expected, in the worst possible way.


13 thoughts on “5 Reasons Why King of Scars by Leigh Bardugo Didn’t Work For Me

  1. Great review Tasya! King of Scars didn’t work for me for similar reasons (mostly Nina). I really wish Nina’s chapters had been excluded because it was jarring and never connected with the main arc. I ended up changing my rating from 3 stars to 2.5 stars because I’m still salty about this book. Lol.


    1. Ah yeahh! I think this is my biggest complain too, I feel like if it’s made another book and I don’t have to trudged through them, the rest of my complaints won’t even be this much. But because I have to forced myself to read and finish this book, they became unbearable! 😦

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Great review! I wholeheartedly agree with you about the Nina chapters – I love her as a character, but they shouldn’t have been there. Hopefully, since most readers agree on this, the next book doens’t have anything like it, but you’re right that giving out ARCs would’ve been a good “early warning” for Leigh. I doubt that they would’ve been taken away, but maybe they could’ve been a little bit more connected to the rest of the plot.

    It’s really unfortunate that most fans weren’t able to connect to this book, especially when Nikolai is such a beloved character 😦


  3. Oh no! I didn’t even notice the descriptive writing, but I also suck at remembering details. Haha! While I didn’t hate the Nina chapters, I do agree that they could’ve been left out. They didn’t seem to add much to the book. I felt the same way about the sarcasm in the Six of Crows duology. I HATED it! For some reason it didn’t bother me as much here. Perhaps because I was so happy to be back in Ravka. XD I will say that I am 100% on board with the ending, but only because the character in question is my absolute favorite and I would have been thrilled with any book he was in! I totally see why each of your points meant this was a disappointment for you though. Great review!


  4. I honestly don’t like the pairing Zoya x Nikolai. I felt that it was “forced” (like the ending). Plus, I thought this was Nikolai’s book but instead it felt like an unnecessary addition to the Grisha series. Imo, it was a disaster. 🍵 But no offense to the fans of the book.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s